Casey looks like he's been asked the most pointless question in the world? Like.... "Yeah." And then, as though the invisible hand of the immortal Cricket Quayle reaches through space and time to give him a light smack in the back of his head, he cuts short before he finishes with "Duh."

Wait, it was "whether or not," not "is he," that's not how you answer the question. But, like, to Casey it sounds like Stokes Sy was framed, and he's not the kind of bro to do sh– stuff, to do stuff like pranks and then not own up to it. He turned himself in last year, didn't he? And since then it's not even like he's been acting like a jerk or whatever, he's been, like, p....retty much a fu– freakin' A N G E L. How many detentions has he gotten since the LGK prank? None. (Casey doesn't know this for sure but he's not about to sound like he doesn't know shit, okay.) And why? Because he's been, like, a good dude, or whatever. Casey says he knows that his cabin has a bad reputation but like, frankly? They've been really sick? They've behaved pretty well and they have two captains and Sy's really good at Quidditch and when Danger Girl pierced Xav's little sister's ear and there was blood everywhere he was, like, the first person to go and carry them to Muffs? And he seemed like he cared a lot?

So.

Like.

Yeah. He's like, fit. .... Huh? Oh. Oh, yeah. AND he's fit to be a CAPTAIN because he's a pretty sick dude and he totally didn't do any of that shit.