gooseberryhigh | Backdated to Prom

Entry tags:

Backdated to Prom

So.. how's everyone doing on the mystery? You may answer under a ward if you don't want to give anything away.

[Added after the mystery is solved]
ESSIE AND I WON! This is so exciting. Thanks everyone who gave me some honest help.

[Added a little after that]
[Warded to Frankie and Ree]
Would you two mind if Milo stayed in our room? No funny business, I promise!

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Are YOU a murderer???

Nope, and I hear that you aren't as well. I'll share info if you do.

Okay, MAYBE I believe you...

Well, I know for SURE that it isn't HAZEL. Or the lead pipe or the billiard room.

What about YOU?

I've had those confirmed for me as well. Got anything else?

It's definitely not Milo or the kitchen, and I've been told the axe wasn't used.

Oh, those were the ones on my cards. UM. I really don't think it was PIPPA but no one has actually told me for sure that they had her card. And I can't rule out POISON, but I think I've ruled out all of the twacking weapons.

I can rule out poison for you. Do you have revolver, statuette, or wrench crossed out?

UM.

I don't have ANYTHING actually CROSSED OUT. It's just in my HEAD. But I don't think anyone has mentioned the STATUETTE.

This is SO HARD.

It SO is. And everyone keeps accusing JEFFY but I can't believe he would LIE to us.

He's got to if he doesn't want to get caught. I mean, if he is even guilty.

I mean I GUESS so. But he was like SUPER believable when he told us it wasn't him. So was BASH.

UM.

Okay.

I am finally trying to write everything down.

Have you heard anything about the LOUNGE or the LIBRARY?

SO FAR:

Ree, Knife, Dining room - all cleared.
I am pretty sure about Essie, Hazel, Will, Jo, and Pippa being safe.

I don't think it was a lead pipe, rope, axe, piano wire, or candlestick.

Not the ballroom, conservatory, kitchen, library, or study either. I think.

WHAT ABOUT YOU?

Ree, piano wire, and the lounge were my cards.

Jo, Milo and myself aren't murderers. Kitchen is safe, too.

I was told it wasn't the billiard room or hall, either.

So it was the bedroom!

It could still be the study. And they could have lied about the conservatory, too.

Gosh this is hard!

I WANT THEM ALL TO BE TELLING THE TRUTH!

I KNOW. But there's at least two people trying to save their own butts.

Honestly I think it's Jeffy and Bash. Or Jeffy and Wyatt. I'm pretty sure it's Jeffy, though.

So, based on what you know and what I know...

The only things we can't exactly cross out are:

Jeffy, Wyatt, and maybe Bash
Revolver, Wrench, and Statuette
Library, and study.

Essie just told me she hasn't heard anything about the statuette, but it's not entirely helpful.

I'm so confused I honestly don't know anymore.

There's still so many possible combinations even with so much narrowed down. I don't know if I can get it in two guesses, especially when they don't confirm for us even one thing that's definitely right or wrong.

Looking back now, I don't know.

Essie seems suspicious believing some people right off the bat are innocent?

And then, no one actually confirmed Pippa wasn't a killer, because you know - Essie said it wasn't Pippa but Essie already said Hazel was her card.

Jeffy is the one who told me about the revolver and all the revolver guesses have been wrong so maybe Jeffy isn't a murderer.

That's just Essie, I think. She wants to think everyone is innocent.

I see Pippa as being sneaky. I could believe her trying to throw everyone off from suspecting her.

I think I'm gonna try to take a crack at this.

I don't know anymore ugh.

I thought we all had it right. D:

Well done!!! I knew you could do it!

Thanks! I don't think I could have done it without Essie's help in the end. I had been told the conservatory was safe so I never would have figured out that it wasn't.

That was me! I was trying to MISDIRECT everyone!!

Edited 2017-05-29 08:37 (UTC)

You're so SNEAKY! Essie not being able to confirm that you weren't one of the murderers just made me suspect you more in the end. I knew you could pull off trying to get everyone to look at someone else if you had to.

Thanks!! I thought about trying to FRAME someone else but I didn't want to draw too much attention to myself.

You played the game well, Pippa. I'm not exactly sure how, but I think there's got to be some way you could have beat us all.

If I'd KNOWN the other murderer was JEFFY we could have teamed up to give each other an alibi. But then you might have got suspicious that no one ELSE could vouch for us. I wanted you all to win, though!

I think you two could have got away with it. I probably wouldn't have thought too hard to realize that could happenz

MAYBE. I guess we'll never know! Anyway, I'm happy you and Essie won the prize!

It's cool with me if it's cool with Frankie!

Edited (oops ) 2017-05-29 14:28 (UTC)

Awesome! Thanks!

Flat | Top-Level Comments Only

Backdated to Prom

Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Essie + Bianca

Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Re: Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

Issy + Bianca

[After the mystery is solved]

[After the mystery is solved]

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

no subject

Ree/Frankie/Bianca

Milo is like o_o "Where did this luck come from"

ree is honestly pretty chill as long as she doesn't think you're putting yourself in mortal danger

Ree/Frankie/Bianca