Of course fish puns are basically an automatic win where Kurt is concerned. Despite being alone in his cabin and reading a piece of paper, he might still blush. He pulls out his own paper and cuts it into a whale shape, writes his response, and slips it (in a similarly unexciting envelope, labeled PIPPA) under the door of the sophomore girls' cabin.

Hi Pippa!

Thanks! That sounds like a fun opportunaty! I bet we'll have a whale of a time!

From,
Kurt

at the bottom is a hastily scribbled

p.s. (that's a yes!)

[it's shaped like this and has the little smiley face on the other side. Kurt may be reasonably artistic, but that doesn't mean I am.]