(no subject)

[gdilevi]

Knife-wielder vs. Wand-wielder: Who would win?

Comments

[chryseis]

Is there an element of surprise?

[gdilevi]

The surprise is that someone is trying to use a knife to threaten someone with a wand.

[chryseis]

Not everyone knows a lot of hexes, though.

[alapai.insanejournal.com]

Wand-wielder. Don't they say not to bring a knife to a gun fight? I believe Indian Jones would agree. Though as Cricket says if there is an element of surprise that changes things.

[nobletoo]

Is the knife-wielder skilled at throwing knives? Or just stabbing people with them?

[gdilevi]

Both.

[nobletoo]

Then it's all just down to skill, isn't it? And reflexes.

[laaurel.insanejournal.com]

Can the knife-wielder do wandless magic??

[gdilevi]

No. But now the leading theory is that it's a knife wand.

[neattrick]

me and sy already figured this out: knife wand

[addytives]

THIS IS EXACTLY WHAT I CAME HERE TO SAY.

[threatens]

He's gotta be a fuckin wizard serial killer, right? Knife wand. Or wand knife. Only explanation.

[dooomcookie]

Depends on if they know how to use it.

[reehobbs.insanejournal.com]

Which it? The knife, the wand, or their ineffable charisma?

[dooomcookie]

The ineffable charisma, of course.

[noblewon]

You're kidding right.

[gdilevi]

Mostly.

[noblewon]

I will debate useless things all day if that's what you're into.

- Is the knife magic?
- Does the knife wielder have and special knife skills?
- Is the knife wielder super sneaky?
- Are they magical?

[firstposition.insanejournal.com]

Wand. There's a reason no one managed to stab You-Know-Who.

[gdilevi]

But what if they were wearing a scary mask when they tried to stab him?

[firstposition.insanejournal.com]

I will protect you from the men in scary masks.

[unregrettable]

Are we talking a regular fight or a more specialized competition? Because I think the knife-wielder might have an advantage in a knife-throwing competition.

[gdilevi]

I'm starting to think he's not a knife thrower if he didn't just go ahead and throw his knife.

[caritasmitis.insanejournal.com]

That's a contest I'd really rather not see...

[thecourtier.insanejournal.com]

How good is the knife wielder's throwing arm?